Aint No Right

I've stayed silent on the P4P and Jane's performances at Lolla 2020. Old news: Perry continues to be the weak link. But it was nice to see them pull out "I Would For You", of all songs. And Dave is bringing it. All that aside, fuck Chris Chaney. I don't give a shit how great a session player he is o...

The songs they performed as Gobalee became the songs on that album. Stephen and Perry had a falling out around '99 and Perry turned it in to a solo endeavor. They had made up again before he finished, hence Perk playing on the title track. Yeah, I vaguely remember this now. I was shocked at the rif...

All of that being said, the song likely had to have existed in some form by 1995-96 if "Hard Charger" was the working title for GGU...at least, you'd think. Kind of hope that's not the case and that they wrote it in 1997...because not including that song on GGU is inexplicable to me. Not knocking G...

If he really wanted to explore what could happen creatively, Perry’s idea of writing a few days a week for a year seemed better than trying to cram in music right before a big tour. Definitely. It's actually a pet peeve of mine when bands do that. You can totally hear that the process was rushed.

Probably the biggest mistake both of them made was thinking they could just do the band and not hash shit out. If they do end up working together again, the absolutely need to resolve the personal shit. Always thought it was interesting that there was simmering tension the whole time, but since the...

Hokahey wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 02, 2020 2:49 pm

Tyler Durden wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 02, 2020 2:40 pm

Still waiting on that Gobbalee album.

I've got good news for you. It came out almost 20 years ago called Song yet to Be Sung.

Wasn't it supposed to be a separate project?

Given Perry's track record, I knew we'd never see/hear it when he first made mention of another album. I just thought it was hilarious at the time and a way to save face...because in my mind, it was pretty damn obvious that the only reason TGEA was even made was because of the interview Eric did wit...

someguy wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 02, 2020 1:24 pm

That sonny interview has not aged well at all lol

In what sense?

Remember not long after The Great Escape Artist was released that Perry started talking about the band making another record. Fast forward 8-9 years and nothing.

https://loudwire.com/janes-addiction-pe ... ng-record/

I'm sure this was discussed at the time here (I don't remember)...but this always struck me a little odd. While Dave makes some fair points (Where's all of Eric's brilliant recordings?), I don't recall Eric trashing everyone in Jane's in Sonny's interview (unless he means convos with industry people...

kv wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 01, 2020 9:17 pm

Etty must fucking hate the power of those old love songs

C'mon kv, "I Would For You" is no "Applause For You"!

All of that being said, the song likely had to have existed in some form by 1995-96 if "Hard Charger" was the working title for GGU...at least, you'd think. Kind of hope that's not the case and that they wrote it in 1997...because not including that song on GGU is inexplicable to me. Not knocking GG...

We may be getting “Ocean Size”. Perk’s Instagram alludes to it. “3,4 -Bam”. Unless they’re just loosening up with that for rehearsal.

So today we have Jane's Addiction at Lolla20. And before, Perry's tribute to Bowie w/Mike Garson (Bowie's long time pianist). Yeah, 10 minute set. Just Because or Been Caught Stealing Jane Says :noclue: The recent pic of the original lineup on Perk's Instagram does have me wondering if there is a t...

Larry B. wrote: ↑

Fri Jul 31, 2020 6:08 pm

The extended version of that song is bliss.

Japhy wrote: ↑

Fri Jul 31, 2020 3:56 pm

Not one for band tees but

Funny...in my 30s, I went through a long period where I felt too dignified for band tees...but now that I’m in my 40s, they’d made a resurgence in my life and I don’t care what anyone thinks. Just got this...

kv wrote: ↑

Thu Jul 30, 2020 10:53 pm

For me GGU and Kettle Whistle was the tap running dry...they both failed to raise the bar...but they were both good and had great moments...

This.

Anyone know why the song "Hard Charger" was scrapped from inclusion as the title track for the renamed Good Gods Urge album? According to JA.org it was supposed to be the name of the Jane's follow-up to Ritual? I don't think I knew that. I definitely didn't know that. But I do remember reading an a...

Anyone know why the song "Hard Charger" was scrapped from inclusion as the title track for the renamed Good Gods Urge album?

Obviously, the Triple X debut is out of print in all physical formats...and the label is now defunct. However, you can buy the album from iTunes and stream it via Spotify. So who owns the rights to this album now? It makes you wonder why this Perry box set is coming out on Capitol while it includes ...