Aint No Right

intertwoven wrote:Not sure who I feel more sorry for, the people in the crowd or the people who buy this release. Watched it on Amazon. The 3 Days drum solo part was cool. No "At this moment" intro. Synth violin in "Of Course" instead of a real violinist. Fake as Perry's current face. Lame. Couldn't help think I'd rather hear these songs sung by Scott Weiland, Chris Cornell, or Chester Bennington, but oh well.

Cant you think of anyone who would do Jane's justice thats still alive?

clickie wrote:

intertwoven wrote:Not sure who I feel more sorry for, the people in the crowd or the people who buy this release. Watched it on Amazon. The 3 Days drum solo part was cool. No "At this moment" intro. Synth violin in "Of Course" instead of a real violinist. Fake as Perry's current face. Lame. Couldn't help think I'd rather hear these songs sung by Scott Weiland, Chris Cornell, or Chester Bennington, but oh well.

Cant you think of anyone who would do Jane's justice thats still alive?

Axl Rose

clickie wrote:

intertwoven wrote:Not sure who I feel more sorry for, the people in the crowd or the people who buy this release. Watched it on Amazon. The 3 Days drum solo part was cool. No "At this moment" intro. Synth violin in "Of Course" instead of a real violinist. Fake as Perry's current face. Lame. Couldn't help think I'd rather hear these songs sung by Scott Weiland, Chris Cornell, or Chester Bennington, but oh well.

Cant you think of anyone who would do Jane's justice thats still alive?

Mike Patton

Six7Six7 wrote:

clickie wrote:

intertwoven wrote:Not sure who I feel more sorry for, the people in the crowd or the people who buy this release. Watched it on Amazon. The 3 Days drum solo part was cool. No "At this moment" intro. Synth violin in "Of Course" instead of a real violinist. Fake as Perry's current face. Lame. Couldn't help think I'd rather hear these songs sung by Scott Weiland, Chris Cornell, or Chester Bennington, but oh well.

Cant you think of anyone who would do Jane's justice thats still alive?

Mike Patton

The world's greatest vocalist would be an interesting choice. Plus we'd get to hear all the high notes in songs again.

Nu Perry makes every old punk metal janes song sound like a journey ballad ...

Bandit72 wrote:

Six7Six7 wrote:

clickie wrote:

intertwoven wrote:Not sure who I feel more sorry for, the people in the crowd or the people who buy this release. Watched it on Amazon. The 3 Days drum solo part was cool. No "At this moment" intro. Synth violin in "Of Course" instead of a real violinist. Fake as Perry's current face. Lame. Couldn't help think I'd rather hear these songs sung by Scott Weiland, Chris Cornell, or Chester Bennington, but oh well.

Cant you think of anyone who would do Jane's justice thats still alive?

Mike Patton

The world's greatest vocalist would be an interesting choice. Plus we'd get to hear all the high notes in songs again.

I'd even go so far as to say that a female vocalist would be an interesting choice.

Karen O has the pipes, the energy, and the weirdness to pull it off. I'd like to see that.

Oh fuck, 67 is spot on.....Patton doing vox in Jane's would be harrowing in a really, really good way. While you're (all of you) at it, round out the rest of the best JA cover band. I think the present one has plateaued.

Taylor Hawkins would be an obvious choice on drums

Tom Morello on guitars.

And Jimmy Chamberlin would be a great addition on drums too!

Mescal wrote:Taylor Hawkins would be an obvious choice on drums

parklife03 wrote:Tom Morello on guitars.

God no, he belongs in RATM and not in that many other places

Morello and Hawkins? Oh god no wtf is wrong with you people?

How about Eric Avery on bass? That'd be interesting.

Jane's Addiction 8.3

Mike Patton - Vox
Tom Morello - Rhythm Guitar
John 5 - Lead Guitar
Mike Inez - Bass
Josh Freese - Drums
Charlie Clouser - Keys

I'd buy my 8 max tickets to that in a heartbeat.

Six7Six7 wrote:Jane's Addiction 8.3

Mike Patton - Vox
Tom Morello - Rhythm Guitar
John 5 - Lead Guitar
Mike Inez - Bass
Josh Freese - Drums
Charlie Clouser - Keys

I'd buy my 8 max tickets to that in a heartbeat.

Introducing hot newcomer Connie Lingus as Etty Farrell [sponsored by Brazzers]

Iggy Pop - Vox
Daniel Ash - Guitar
Billy Duffy - Guitar
Mike Watt - Bass
Mike Portnoy - Drums

Pandemonium wrote:Iggy Pop - Vox
Daniel Ash - Guitar
Billy Duffy - Guitar
Mike Watt - Bass
Mike Portnoy - Drums

That sounds truly awful in my head.

Iggy Pop is fuckin cool suggestion

Six7Six7 wrote:

Pandemonium wrote:Iggy Pop - Vox
Daniel Ash - Guitar
Billy Duffy - Guitar
Mike Watt - Bass
Mike Portnoy - Drums

That sounds truly awful in my head.

Hey, I was going to suggest Iron Maiden's Steve Harris on bass and Eddie Van Halen on 2nd guitar/keyboards.

Rhythm guitar? I really like the idea of Mike Portnoy on drums. His power, intuition, and ability would bring some bright new color to the mix. Freese is great....I had never been 'disappointed' with him until I recently saw a clip of him with Sting where he couldn't come close to mimicking the Copeland magic. Guitar is hard....hard to insert someone into what I feel was a mixture of naiveté, exuberance, confusion, anger, and grief compounded by heroic amounts of heroin. Similarly the bass, sans the grief....drizzled with some books, Brahms, and Joy Division.

Steve'd be great

SR wrote:Rhythm guitar? I really like the idea of Mike Portnoy on drums. His power, intuition, and ability would bring some bright new color to the mix. Freese is great....I had never been 'disappointed' with him until I recently saw a clip of him with Sting where he couldn't come close to mimicking the Copeland magic. Guitar is hard....hard to insert someone into what I feel was a mixture of naiveté, exuberance, confusion, anger, and grief compounded by heroic amounts of heroin. Similarly the bass, sans the grief....drizzled with some books, Brahms, and Joy Division.

I saw Sting in Buenos Aires a few months ago, with Josh Freese, and I was really disappointed. I also saw Sting with Vinnie Colaiuta on his past tour, and it was a HUGE diference.