Do you think Kurt had zero participation in the writing of that album?
I dont think you'd honestly answer "no."
So it's not a ridiculous stretch to think he wrote most of it. Much less of a ridiculous stretch when to consider Courtney murdering him.
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2020 9:14 pm
by JOEinPHX
He co-wrote a b-side.
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2020 9:40 pm
by intertwoven
"Old Age" was a pretty cool unfinished Nirvana track that Courtney put her own spin on. Don't think she tried to pass it off as her own, but I'm no expert on the matter. And then she played that "You Got No Right" or whatever unreleased song on Unplugged and introduced it as a Kurt song. I think Kurt was her Casey.. bouncing ideas off and looking for feedback, but not like he was the ghost-writer.
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2020 10:45 pm
by Stickyfingers
Im not a big Nirvana fan
but In Utero is a masterpiece, one of best rock albums ever,
the album have a clear inspiration from his life with Courtney, I think Kurt really loved that bitch.
My favourite Nirvana song is an unreleased bside
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Sat Mar 07, 2020 9:09 pm
by someguy
I just had a thought- does anyone have any access to music trading circles? It might be circulating that way...
Circle of the Noose was exclusively going around within those circles for a long time so maybe there's a chance its out there also?
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 7:42 am
by Noonesshocking
Guy at the bottom of this thread (NIN forum) says it’s been in trading circles for like a decade. However - isn’t this the jasper guy that left years ago after flipping out in NIN threads and that movie thread? If so, that would make the claim less credible.
Guy at the bottom of this thread (NIN forum) says it’s been in trading circles for like a decade. However - isn’t this the jasper guy that left years ago after flipping out in NIN threads and that movie thread? If so, that would make the claim less credible.
I forgot that guys name but it wasn't Jasper. You are correct that he melted down a few times like Jasper. He had NY in his user name. Anyone with a better memory than me?
Not that I am in the trading circles anymore but I don't think it is out there.
Guy at the bottom of this thread (NIN forum) says it’s been in trading circles for like a decade. However - isn’t this the jasper guy that left years ago after flipping out in NIN threads and that movie thread? If so, that would make the claim less credible.
I forgot that guys name but it wasn't Jasper. You are correct that he melted down a few times like Jasper. He had NY in his user name. Anyone with a better memory than me?
Not that I am in the trading circles anymore but I don't think it is out there.
NYRexall or something like that??
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 9:15 am
by Hokahey
He asks if they removed it from YouTube again so he clearly doesn't know what he's talking about.
"Old Age" was a pretty cool unfinished Nirvana track that Courtney put her own spin on. Don't think she tried to pass it off as her own, but I'm no expert on the matter. And then she played that "You Got No Right" or whatever unreleased song on Unplugged and introduced it as a Kurt song. I think Kurt was her Casey.. bouncing ideas off and looking for feedback, but not like he was the ghost-writer.
Yup..."Old Age" was cowritten by Kurt and credited as such; released by Hole when Kurt was alive.
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Wed Apr 15, 2020 9:57 am
by Tyler Durden
After 26 years, does anyone have any concrete evidence that Kurt wrote Live Through This...or just the same old speculation?
Re: Laughing Beats - unreleased song
Posted: Wed Apr 15, 2020 1:44 pm
by Mescal
I don't think there is any proof.
But isn't it naive thinking that Courtney didn't ask for his opinion while she was writing?
